Home / Recruiting Strategies / Talent Acquisition / The Top Ten: Are You Guilty of these Common Hiring Mistakes?

The Top Ten: Are You Guilty of these Common Hiring Mistakes?

The Top Ten: Are You Guilty of these Common Hiring Mistakes?

By: Roberta Chinsky Matuson

I’ve been in business for 13 years and have seen my share of recruiting mistakes made by business owners, many that could certainly have been avoided. Here is my top ten list of common mistakes business owners make, along with advice on how to avoid following suit.

1. Failure to hire for fit Think about a job that you worked in that didn’t work out. Was it because you didn’t have the skills to do the job or was it because your values did not align with the organization? I’m betting most likely it was because you didn’t fit into the culture of the organization. Hire for fit, train for skill and you should be able to slash costly turnover.

2. Poor interviewing skills I recently had a former business owner tell me that he would hire people who volunteered to help him out at the events that his company was working at. These people wound up being “Mr. Right” for right now, but turned out to be some of his worst hiring decisions. Learn how to use behavior-based interviewing techniques to assess whether this should be one date or more of a long-term relationship.

3. Expecting employees to act like owners The only people who act like owners are people who have a stake in the business. If you want your people to act like owners then share the profits.

4. Tossing people into management based on seniority I’ve heard this story so many times I could repeat it without looking at the script. Employee number five has been in the department longer than anyone else so this employee is promoted to management. Doesn’t matter that he or she is not interested in managing people or that they don’t have the qualities one usually seeks in a manager. This story never has a happy ending. Either frustrated employees, who are saddled with this boss, quit or the manager goes down in flames because they never really stood a chance. Hire or promote people who have the desire and the aptitude for a leadership role.

5. Dropping new employees into their chairs without any training I understand you may be hiring experienced people who should know exactly what to do but the reality is that work gets done differently in every organization. Have a well-laid out onboarding plan to smoothly assimilate employees into your organization and watch productivity of new hires soar!

6. Failure to manage performance Please don’t tell me you don’t have a performance management process in place because that sounds like something only the big companies use. There is a reason they have these processes in place. People like to know what’s expected of them and they also like to know when they are not meeting expectations so they can improve. Don’t believe me? Ask your employees. That which gets measured gets done. If you want to maximize productivity then manage performance.

7. Retaining poor performers I hear, “Well, this person really isn’t working out,” all the time. Really? Then why the heck are they still here? Start replacing your B players with A players and you will see performance improvements all around the organization.

8. Lack of structure Most entrepreneurs come from bureaucratic companies and vow to keep things loose in their own organization. Loose is one thing, chaotic is another. At some point you have to put a strong foundation in place in order to maintain or increase revenues. It will cost ten times more to fix a mess, than to prevent one from happening. Put the right structure in place so that you can focus on what you do best. Growing your business.

9. Treated people the same Equal is not fair, yet owners often give everyone the same increase or autonomy regardless of contribution or experience. Telling a top performing three-year veteran employee they cannot telecommute one day a week because it wouldn’t be fair to others will do little to inspire additional commitment. Treat people like individuals. Reward those who deserve to be rewarded and be prepared to tell others why they too are not receiving the same treatment.

10. Doing everything on your own If you can really do everything on your own, then why isn’t everything getting done? I just outsourced a project that I knew was going to take me a full day to complete. This would take away from the time I could better invest in marketing my services. Know thyself. Stop holding yourself back and use outside resources to strengthen your organization. In the end, you’ll be glad you did.

You can avoid making all of these common mistakes by doing things differently. What are you waiting for?

© 2010 Human Resource Solutions. All rights reserved.

Author Bio
Roberta Chinsky Matuson
is the President of Human Resource Solutions and is the author of the forthcoming book, Suddenly in Charge: Managing Up, Managing Down, Succeeding All Around, (Nicholas Brealey, January 2011.) Her firm helps organizations accelerate productivity and profitability by increasing employee engagement. Sign up to receive Roberta’s complimentary newsletter, HR Matters.